18 Nov Should You Train Through Pain? When to Keep Going and When to Back Off
Say your knee’s been grumbling on your Swan River loops for a couple of weeks, or your shoulder twinges every time you press overhead. You don’t want to lose your fitness and you’re sick of guessing. Do you push on, or pull the pin?
Here’s the honest answer. A bit of discomfort while you train isn’t automatically a sign you’re doing damage, and for many niggles, staying active with some tweaks tends to be better than stopping everything. What matters is the type of pain, how strong it gets, and how you feel the next morning. Sharp pain, pain that keeps climbing, swelling or a joint that gives way are different. Those are signs to back off and get it checked.
Normal soreness or something more?
DOMS (delayed onset muscle soreness) is the ache that turns up a day or so after a new or harder session, like the stairs feeling cruel two days after a big leg day. It’s usually a dull, spread-out ache in the muscles you worked, often on both sides, and it tends to ease as you warm up and move. It generally fades over a few days.
Pain that may point to an injury behaves differently. It often starts during the session or soon after, sits in one specific spot, feels sharp, catching or pinchy, or gets worse the more you do.
Plenty of niggles sit somewhere in the middle, like a tendon that aches at the start of a run, settles once you’re warm, then grumbles that evening. That middle zone is where a simple monitoring system is really useful.
A simple traffic light for training with pain
Many physios and other clinicians use a version of what’s often called the pain monitoring model. It came out of rehab research on Achilles and knee problems, and it gives you a way to keep training without guessing. Rate your pain from 0 (none) to 10 (the worst you can imagine), then use it like a traffic light.
- Green, roughly 0 to 2: carry on as planned.
- Amber, roughly 3 to 5: usually OK to keep going, as long as it’s your familiar ache rather than something new and sharp, and it passes the next-morning check below.
- Red, above 5, or sharp, or climbing as you go: stop that exercise for today and change something.
These numbers are a common starting point, not a hard rule. Clinicians set different limits for different problems, and some will want you lower than 5, so if you’re already seeing someone, follow their numbers.
The next-morning check
How it feels during a session can be misleading. Adrenaline, a good warm-up and the person on the next rack all make it easy to push a bit too far. The next morning is more honest.
Pick one simple test you can repeat each day, like your first steps out of bed for a heel or Achilles, a few stairs or a squat to a chair for a knee, or lifting your arm to the side for a shoulder. Compare it with how it felt the previous morning.
- Same or better: the load was probably about right. You can repeat it, or build up a little.
- Worse: you likely did a bit too much. Ease back next session rather than stopping completely.
- Getting worse week on week, or waking you at night: it’s time to change the plan and get it looked at.
Modify, don’t just stop
Complete rest feels safe, but for many overuse niggles it isn’t the whole answer. Tissues tend to need some load to adapt, and stopping everything can leave the area less ready for training when you come back. The aim is usually to find a level your body can handle right now, then build from there.
You’ve got plenty of levers to pull. You can drop the weight or the reps, shorten the range so you stay out of the painful bit, slow the tempo, or swap the exercise. Box squats instead of deep squats, a landmine press instead of an overhead press, or flat walking and cycling instead of hill sprints are all common swaps.
When things settle, add back load gradually, one thing at a time, and keep using the next-morning check. If you’re a lifter, our post on lower back pain after deadlifts goes through this for the back. Runners might find our guide to knee pain from running useful.
When to stop and see a doctor
Some symptoms aren’t about training load at all. Stop and get medical help if you notice any of these:
- Chest pain or pressure, unusual breathlessness, dizziness or fainting during exercise. Call 000.
- A pop or snap with sudden pain, rapid swelling, an obvious deformity, or you can’t put weight on the leg.
- Numbness, pins and needles or weakness spreading down an arm or leg, or changes in bladder or bowel control.
- Severe muscle pain and swelling after a very hard session, especially with dark, cola-coloured urine.
- Pain with fever, feeling unwell, or unexplained weight loss.
- Calf pain with swelling, warmth or redness.
- Constant pain at night that doesn’t ease with changing position.
For most of these, see your GP promptly. For chest symptoms, a suspected break or anything that feels severe, go to an emergency department or call 000.
When it’s worth getting checked
You don’t need an appointment for every bit of DOMS. It’s worth getting a niggle assessed if it’s still there after a week or two of sensible changes, if you keep landing in the red zone, if it keeps coming back every time you build up, or if it’s changing how you move, sleep or work.
An assessment looks at where the pain is coming from, how you move and what your training involves, then helps you plan what to keep, change and build back. At Beyond Health, our chiropractors in Osborne Park and Applecross see plenty of gym, running and sport niggles. Our physio, Pádraig Hughes, consults at Osborne Park two Mondays a month, and remedial massage is also available there. For foot and heel pain from running, there’s podiatry at Applecross. You can read more about how we approach sports injuries too.
If you’re not sure whether you need anything at all, come in for a free screening. It’s a short chat and a few simple movement checks to see whether chiro or physio may suit you. It isn’t treatment and there’s no obligation. You can book online, or call Applecross on (08) 6311 7646 or Osborne Park on 0435 668 595.
FAQs
Is it OK to train with DOMS?
Usually, yes. Light to moderate exercise often helps DOMS ease. You might choose to train a different muscle group or go a bit lighter until it settles. If the soreness is severe, isn’t easing after a few days, or comes with swelling or dark urine, see a GP.
How do I know if pain is DOMS or an injury?
DOMS is typically a dull, spread-out ache that starts a day or so after training and eases as you move. Injury pain is more often sharp, in one specific spot, starts during the session, or gets worse with activity. If you’re unsure, have it assessed.
Should I stop exercising completely if something hurts?
Often not. For many niggles, modifying the load, range or exercise lets you keep training while it settles. Stop and get checked if pain is sharp, climbing, causing swelling or giving way, or if you notice numbness or weakness.
Can I run through shin or knee pain?
Sometimes, if it stays in the green or amber zone and passes the next-morning check. If it’s sharp, very localised on the bone, causes a limp or keeps getting worse week to week, back off and get it assessed.
Should I take painkillers so I can keep training?
Masking pain to get through a session can make it harder to read what your body is telling you. Talk to your GP or pharmacist about pain medication, and use the traffic light and next-morning check to guide how much you do.
This article is general information only and isn’t a substitute for personalised advice. Everyone’s different, so please see a registered health professional about your own situation, and seek urgent medical care if you have severe or worrying symptoms.





No Comments